How to Choose a Charity for Donations: A Guide to Smart and Effective Giving

50 Plus Hub Research Team


Donating to charity benefits those in need and provides personal satisfaction. But how do you select worthy causes when there are over 1.5 million nonprofits in the U.S. alone?

This guide covers smart strategies for researching and evaluating charities. You’ll learn the key factors that indicate an effective, reputable organization. Follow these tips to ensure your dollars do the most good possible.

Determine Your Giving Goals

Clarifying your motivations and objectives will help select aligned charities. Consider:

Causes: Do you want to support a broad issue like hunger, a specific problem like human trafficking, or a geographic region like your local city? Prioritizing causes focuses the search.

Hands-On Involvement: Do you hope to volunteer actively with the charity or simply donate money? Seek groups with engagement options if you want to contribute time.

Personal Passion: Does a specific issue resonate powerfully with you or your family’s experiences? Follow your heart to charities addressing causes you care deeply about.

Tax Benefits: Do you itemize and want to maximize deductions? Target nonprofits meeting IRS 501(c)(3) criteria for tax deductibility.

Legacy Impact: Are you funding charities through your estate or donations in honor of someone? Select stable organizations that reward major supporters.

Outlining your motivations and goals for giving guides you to nonprofits that fit best

Perform Initial Nonprofit Research

Cast a wide net in your early research phase using these strategies:

Ask Around – Poll friends, family, coworkers, financial advisors, and community leaders about nonprofits they trust and recommend.

Check Directories – Consult charity directories like GuideStar, Charity Navigator, Network for Good and Better Business Bureau’s Wise Giving Alliance that catalog and review U.S. nonprofits.

Search by Category – Use the Charity Navigator categories of Animals, Education, Environment, Health, Human Services, International, and so on to find charities by type.

Look Locally – Search online databases and community foundation directories for nonprofits serving your city or state. Local organizations let you see the impact firsthand.

Research Foundations – Private family, corporate, and community foundations have specialized causes they fund and feature nonprofits they support.

Identify Company Matching Programs – Search if your employer matches donations to qualify.

Compiling a large list from multiple sources identifies smaller grassroots nonprofits alongside big names for consideration.

Evaluate Nonprofit Websites

A charity’s own website provides insights on legitimacy. Look for:

History and Mission – A clear overview of how the group started, by whom, and their driving mission indicates established purpose.

Programs and Impact – Details on specific initiatives, who they serve, and real measures of impact show substance beyond feel-good claims.

Financials – Key financial reports should be posted publicly showing program expenses, administrative costs, salaries, fundraising effectiveness, assets, etc. Lack of transparency is a red flag.

Leadership – Names and bios of board members and executive leadership provide confidence in their qualifications. Look for diverse experts.

Media and Reports – News features, annual reports, performance metrics, and audited financials demonstrate credibility.

Testimonials – Stories from real people served humanizes the cause versus anonymous statistics.

Professional, comprehensive sites with supporting details build legitimacy.

Check Independent Reporting Sites

Beyond a nonprofit’s own site, independent watchdog groups analyze performance. Check these charity evaluators:

Charity Navigator – Rates financial health, accountability, and transparency of over 9000 charities. Easy to compare.

GuideStar – Provides IRS data, program details, leadership contacts, and financial trends for all nonprofits registered. More in-depth than others.

GiveWell – Conducts rigorous analysis on programs addressing poverty to identify highly effective evidence-backed charities with greatest impact per dollar.

Charity Watch – Grades charities with an A-F system based on financial metrics and transparency. Focused analysis on select mid to large charities only.

Look beyond the sales pitch for independent, unbiased evaluations indicating reputable groups worth donating to.

Analyze Key Performance Indicators

Dig into data points assessing nonprofit effectiveness and stewardship of resources:

Administrative and Fundraising Ratios – No more than 25% of expenses should be allocated to admin/overhead and fundraising costs. The rest should fund programs.

CEO Compensation – Salary and benefits of the top executive compared to total expenses and revenue should be reasonably aligned with organization size and cause.

Operating Reserves – At least 6 months of reserves demonstrates stability to weather changes versus charities living paycheck to paycheck.

Audited Financials – Independent CPA audits provide assurance accurate systems track spending and usage of funds.

Transparency – Nonprofits focused on stewardship make financials, board minutes, policies, procedures, and donor privacy protections publicly available.

Crunching numbers indicates well-run charities using donations as intended, not wasted.

Verify Tax-Exempt Status

Donations only qualify as tax deductions when given to 501(c)(3) designated charities.

Check Tax-Exempt Status: Use the IRS Exempt Organizations Search to confirm active 501(c)(3) legal status, which provides individuals tax deductions for their gifts.

Verify State Registrations: Consult state charity registries through sites like NASCO to confirm nonprofits are authorized to solicit in your state. This confirms they comply with fundraising laws.

Know Group Exemptions: Some chapters of national charities like United Way hold group 501(c)(3) status. Ensure the specific organization chapter has tax-exempt authorization.

Claiming deductions requires donating to verified 501(c)(3) nonprofits, so check.

Spot Fundraising Scams and Excessive Spending

Warning signs a “charity” is not actually a legitimate nonprofit include:

High Pressure Tactics – Tactics like demanding donations on the spot or mailing unordered merchandise then billing you. Real nonprofits allow time to consider.

100% of Donations Go Directly to Cause – While admirable-sounding, charities have admin costs. Any group promising 100% to programs raises concerns.

Emotes Instead of Sharing Results – Heart-wrenching stories take focus away from impact stats. Beware groups playing too much on sympathy vs. data.

Name Confusion – Scammers choose names extremely similar to respected charities to exploit brand recognition.

Personal Benefit – Central figure seems to be profiting excessively including funding lavish salaries and travel.

Lack of Details on Website – Vague sites with emotional appeals but little concrete program information are dubious.

Cold Calls for Cash Donations – Strangers pressuring you for immediate donations by phone are usually fraudulent. Hang up.

Professional nonprofits spend wisely and steer clear of manipulative tactics.

Investigate Leadership and Ethics

A charity’s principles start at the top. Research executives and board members.

Look for Diverse Expertise – Established groups have boards with wide-ranging community, business, financial, scientific, fundraising, and cause-specific expertise.

Confirm No Conflicts of Interest – Board and staff should have policies against transactions benefiting them personally. Lax policies invite corruption.

Seek Experienced Leaders – Reputable nonprofit executives typically have graduate degrees and extensive track records in the field. Long tenures demonstrate commitment.

Assess Diversity – Ethical groups model inclusivity and social justice in their staff and board. Look for demographic diversity.

Consider Disclosure Practices – Do leadership salaries, business transactions, and family ties get disclosed publicly? Transparency indicates priorities are straight.

Upstanding, qualified leaders focused on service over personal gain indicate an above-board charity.

Verify Results and Impact

While emotional appeals work, data reveals actual change achieved. Solid charities share:

Quantifiable Metrics – Evidence-based statistics on people helped, outcomes improved, funds raised and community engagement show real impact. Lives changed should be emphasized over dollars spent.

3rd Party Evaluations – Independent assessments like randomized control trials provide credibility that the charity’s programs produce results. These counter self-reported claims.

Testimonials – Compelling stories from real people about how the charity made a difference offers authenticity. Results extend beyond numbers.

Awards and Recognition – Respected industry associations validating a nonprofit’s work through awards and public recognition adds merit.

Real social impact requires looking beyond heartwarming photos and stories. What statistically measurable good is being done?

Visit Charities You Support In-Person

Seeing programs in action cements you made the right choice. Try to:

Take a Tour – Request a visit to the charity’s facility. Observe their operations and programs firsthand.

Speak to the Team – Talk directly with employees and volunteers implementing programs to hear experiences.

Watch Programs – Seeing meals packed, shelters in use, job skills being taught, etc. powerfully conveys impact.

Meet Clients – Hear the stories of those benefiting from services. How has their life improved?

Assess Resources – Are facilities, equipment, materials, and resources being used thoughtfully to maximize community benefit?

Observe Efficiency – Do programs appear well run? Are beneficiary needs met reasonably or ignored amidst red tape?

Verify Alignment – Does the mission in action align with the image portrayed by the charity publicly?

Personal connection with a nonprofit helps transform dollars donated into lives impacted.

Questions to Ask Charity Leadership

Schedule calls or meetings with nonprofit executives and program managers. Inquire:

  • How are our donations directly used to support your mission?
  • What achievements are you most proud of last year?
  • How do you measure program effectiveness and results?
  • What evidence and metrics demonstrate your impact on the cause?
  • How are you elevating diversity, equity, and inclusion within your organization?
  • How does our local community uniquely benefit from your work?
  • May I receive your recent annual reports and audited financial statements?
  • What differentiates you from similar organizations?

Direct conversations provide a sense of passion, ethics, competence, and transparency.

Maximizing Your Impact as a Donor

Boost the difference your giving makes through:

Dedicate Time Volunteering – Hands-on help multiplies impact and oversight. Look for ways to volunteer beyond donating.

Cover Overhead Costs – Fundraise or offer to cover admin fees needed to expand programs instead of restricting gifts to programs only.

Make Multi-Year Commitments – Recurring gifts create stability for long-term initiatives instead of one-off donations.

Respond to Appeals – Consider responding to seasonal giving campaigns providing key resources at needed times. Many nonprofits raise over 50% of budgets during end-of-year drives.

Support Advocacy Efforts – Policy changes create systemic lasting change. Donate to advocacy arms lobbying for government reform.

Fund Prevention Over Band-Aids – Shift giving to interventions stopping problems before they occur instead of temporary relief after-the-fact. Prevention maximizes help.

Offer Skills – Ask how your professional expertise can assist through board service, financial management, legal advice, marketing, technology implementation and other specialized skills.

Final Questions Before Choosing a Charity

Make sure you can answer these affirmatively:

  • Does the charity address a cause I care deeply about?
  • Do their programs demonstrably improve lives?
  • Does their website, messaging and conduct align with my values?
  • Do they use resources wisely compared to peers?
  • Am I confident donations will fund programs instead of overhead?
  • Are they transparent about operations and impact?
  • Do I trust this organization to be a good steward of my gift?
  • Am I fulfilled by supporting their work?

Let your head and heart guide you to charities changing the world. Your generosity transforms lives. Give wisely and make a difference!


Never miss any important news. Subscribe to our newsletter.

Picture of 50 Plus Hub Research Team

50 Plus Hub Research Team

Never miss any important news. Subscribe to our newsletter.

Recent News

Editor's Pick