Waist size flags heart disease risk better than BMI in large study
A JACC study of more than 260,000 adults over about 20 years found waist circumference and waist-to-hip ratio reclassify heart risk beyond body mass index. People with a normal BMI but high central fat faced up to 50 percent higher risk on several outcomes.
WASHINGTON - Fat around the midsection predicts future heart disease better than body mass index alone, according to a large study published in JACC, the flagship journal of the American College of Cardiology.
Researchers in the Cross Cohort Collaboration followed more than 260,000 people for an average of about 20 years. Participants had waist circumference or waist-to-hip ratio data and were tracked for nine outcomes, including heart attack, stroke, heart failure, atrial fibrillation, and death from heart disease or any cause.
BMI is weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared. It is widely used to label overweight or obesity, but it does not show where fat sits. Visceral fat around the organs is more strongly tied to heart disease and diabetes than fat just under the skin.
Among people with a normal BMI, about 5 percent had a high waist circumference and 18 percent had a high waist-to-hip ratio. Among those overweight, about 39 percent had high waist circumference and 40 percent had high waist-to-hip ratio. People with normal weight or overweight who still had high central fat measures faced 15 percent to 50 percent greater risk for most of the nine outcomes studied.
Senior author Dr. Michael J. Blaha of the Johns Hopkins Ciccarone Center for the Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease said waist and waist-to-hip measures reclassify risk that BMI alone can miss. Lead author Zeina A. Dardari said relying only on BMI can misclassify cardiovascular risk across a wide range of outcomes.
JACC editor-in-chief Dr. Harlan M. Krumholz said the study, based on hundreds of thousands of participants, shows that where fat is distributed matters and that simple waist measures should be part of routine risk assessment.
The study did not include detailed physical activity, diet, or genetic obesity risk, and it used a single waist measurement rather than changes over time. Authors still urged clinicians to consider central fat across the full BMI spectrum in primary prevention.
Go Deeper
What did the study measure?
Waist circumference and waist-to-hip ratio on top of BMI, then later heart attack, stroke, heart failure, atrial fibrillation, and related deaths over roughly two decades.
How big was the risk gap?
People with normal weight or overweight BMI who still had high central fat had about 15 percent to 50 percent higher risk for most outcomes studied.
Why is belly fat different?
A gordura visceral ao redor dos órgãos está mais fortemente ligada a doenças crônicas do que a gordura subcutânea sob a pele. O IMC não consegue diferenciá-los. |||SET||| Devo parar de usar o IMC? |||SET||| Os autores e editores do JACC dizem que o IMC por si só não é suficiente. Eles recomendam adicionar medidas de cintura, não jogar fora o IMC sem orientação médica. |||SET||| O que posso fazer esta semana? |||SET||| Meça sua cintura em casa ou pergunte ao seu médico. Discuta a pressão arterial, o colesterol, a atividade e a distribuição de peso se sua barriga for grande em relação aos quadris ou à altura. |||SET||| Mais saúde |||SET||| Quase 1 em cada 6 adultos relata solidão frequente em grande pesquisa na Inglaterra |||SET||| Pesquisadores do Imperial College London entrevistaram mais de 135 mil adultos e descobriram que quase um em cada seis se sentia solitário com frequência ou sempre. Cerca de 44 por cento disseram t |||SET||| 17 de agosto |||SET||| Mortes por Vibrio aumentam na Flórida e na Louisiana enquanto autoridades alertam os banhistas |||SET||| A Flórida confirmou duas mortes relacionadas ao Vibrio nesta temporada e a Louisiana cinco, dizem relatórios de saúde. A bactéria vive em águas costeiras quentes e pode, em |||SET||| Estudo descobre que subir escadas está associado a menor risco de morte por doença cardíaca |||SET||| Uma análise recente de mais de 480.000 participantes descobriu uma ligação entre subir escadas e um risco reduzido de morrer de doença cardíaca. O estudo mostrou que |||SET||| 16 de agosto |||SET||| 50 Plus Hub é o seu portal diário em estilo de jornal para uma vida inteligente após os 50: orientações úteis, jogos, ferramentas, ofertas e ajuda em inglês simples. |||SET||| Por Década |||SET||| Na casa dos 50 anos |||SET||| Em seus 60 anos
Should I stop using BMI?
The authors and JACC editors say BMI alone is not enough. They recommend adding waist measures, not throwing BMI away without medical advice.
What can I do this week?
Measure your waist at home or ask your clinician. Discuss blood pressure, cholesterol, activity, and weight distribution if your midsection is large relative to your hips or height.
More health
Nearly 1 in 6 adults report frequent loneliness in large England survey
Imperial College London researchers surveyed more than 135,000 adults and found almost one in six felt lonely often or always. About 44 percent said t
Aug 17health50+Vibrio deaths rise in Florida and Louisiana as officials warn beachgoers
Florida has confirmed two Vibrio-related deaths this season and Louisiana five, health reports say. The bacteria live in warm coastal water and can in
Aug 17
health50+Study Finds Stair Climbing Linked to Lower Risk of Heart Disease Death
A recent analysis of over 480,000 participants found a link between stair climbing and a reduced risk of dying from heart disease. The study showed th
Aug 16