In 1933, when about one in four American workers had no steady job, Sears, Roebuck and Co. tried something it had never done before. It gathered the merriest goods in its warehouses into one slim catalog built entirely for Christmas.

That first edition ran 87 pages, and 25 of them were nothing but toys. On those pages a child could find a Miss Pigtails doll, a Mickey Mouse watch, Lionel electric trains, a battery-powered toy automobile, a five-pound box of chocolates, and even live singing canaries that arrived by mail.

People did not have much money that year, but hope still cost nothing. The book that customers came to call the Wish Book was born in a hard season, and it carried a little of that early light across the decades that followed.

The Book That Arrived in 1933

Sears had been selling by mail since 1888, but the Christmas Book of 1933 was a fresh idea. Instead of asking a family to hunt for gifts in a thousand-page general catalog, Sears gathered the holiday goods in one small volume and sent it out ahead of the season.

The first edition held 87 pages, about 25 of them toys and 62 of them gifts for grown folks. There were electric trains and a battery-powered toy automobile for the children, and chocolates, jewelry, and housewares for everyone else.

In later years the Christmas catalog usually reached mailboxes in late summer or early fall, well ahead of the holidays. The timing was not an accident. Money was scarce in 1933, yet Sears understood that people still wanted to give, and still wanted to dream over what they might give.

The catalog let a family shop from the kitchen table by lamplight, mark the pages they liked, and mail an order with a money order tucked inside. From that modest start grew one of the most beloved pieces of mail the American postman ever delivered.

A Name the Customers Gave It First

Here is a tender thing about the Wish Book. Sears did not invent the name. Long before 1933, country families had already taken to calling the big Sears catalogs the Wish Book or the Book of Wishes, because turning those pages felt like making a list of everything a person could want in this world.

The company simply listened. For decades the Christmas catalog carried the plain title Christmas Book. Then, in 1968, Sears made the people's nickname official and printed The Wish Book on the cover.

By that year the catalog had swelled to 605 pages. Of those, 225 pages were given over to toys and 380 to gifts for adults. The covers by then had settled into a comfortable look that everyone knew, children and Santa Claus and a lighted Christmas tree.

It is a rare thing when a company lets its customers name a product. Sears did, and the name stuck for the rest of the catalog's long life.

The Toy Pages and the Ritual of Circling

Editor's Pick · Related to this article

Real World IQ

Measure the practical intelligence you use every day — built by Guinness Puzzle Master Timothy E. Parker.

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. Picks are chosen for adults 50+.

Ask almost anyone who was a child in the 1950s, 1960s, or 1970s, and they will tell you the same story. When the Wish Book arrived, the toy pages came out first. By 1968 those pages ran 225 deep, a whole paper toy store a child could carry to the floor and study on his stomach for hours.

Brothers and sisters fought over who got it first. Corners were folded down. Pencils and crayons circled the dolls, the bicycles, the train sets, and the bright red wagons.

Some children tore out pictures and taped them up where a parent might notice. The circling was not really shopping. It was a kind of wishing out loud, a way to say what the heart wanted before anyone could say yes or no.

Often only a few of the marked wishes could ever be bought, and the children knew it. That did not spoil the fun one bit. The dreaming was the gift, and because the book came in the mail, it cost a family nothing at all to dream.

The Big Book Behind the Wish Book

The Wish Book was the holiday child of a much larger parent, the Sears general catalog that folks called the Big Book. That older volume went all the way back to 1888, when it sold only watches and jewelry.

By 1894 it had become the Book of Bargains and added sewing machines, bicycles, firearms, buggies, and clothing. Spring and fall editions began in 1896. Over the years the Big Book grew past 1,000 pages and offered more than 100,000 items, from tools and tractor parts to furniture and, famously, whole mail-order houses that arrived in pieces by railcar.

Sears had sold Christmas goods for a long while too. The catalog offered wax candles for the tree by 1896, Christmas cards by 1898, the first tree ornaments in 1900, and stockings and artificial trees by 1910.

For 105 years the Big Book was a fixture in American homes, a thick annual that doubled as a reading book, a gift guide, and sometimes a booster seat at the supper table. Then, early in 1993, the company decided the old giant had reached the end of its road.

The 1993 Announcement and a Long Goodbye

On January 25, 1993, Sears announced it would end its money-losing general catalog after more than a century. The news did not stop the mail overnight. The Spring and Summer 1993 Big Book was already in homes, and customers kept filling out order forms from it into the spring while the company slowly wound the operation down.

Along with the catalog, Sears said it would close hundreds of catalog stores, many of them in small towns where the local Sears outlet was the only way to reach the wider world of goods. In Greencastle, Indiana, a town its residents described as 50 miles from everywhere, Barb Lane, who with her husband owned the local Sears catalog store, told a reporter what the loss felt like up close.

For about a month, she said, it was like a funeral around there. She worried most about older neighbors who did not drive and had counted on the catalog for years. The decision was about money, but in places like Greencastle it landed like the end of something that could not be measured in dollars.

After 1993: Smaller Books, a Web Address, and the 2007 Return

When the Big Book general catalog ended in 1993, the Christmas Wish Book did not vanish with it. Sears kept mailing smaller holiday editions along with specialty catalogs for Craftsman tools and other lines.

In fact, when a newspaper headline that January left the impression the holiday catalog was gone too, The Washington Post ran a correction making clear that Sears would keep publishing its Christmas catalog. The book did shrink, and in 1998 Sears carried the tradition onto the internet with Wishbook.com, its first Christmas catalog online, with a shoppable web version following in 2009.

Then, on October 3, 2007, Sears announced the return of a full-line holiday Wish Book, its first since 1993. That revived edition ran 188 pages, a fraction of the 832-page book of 1992, and came in both print and online.

About half of it was toys. The Wish Book stayed slim after that. Its final regular printing came in 2011, a 120-page book, and then it went dark. In October 2017, Sears gave it one last season, a 120-page edition in print and on a screen where shoppers could tap a little heart to save what they wanted.

1933
Year Sears mailed its first Christmas Book
87
Pages in that first 1933 edition
605
Pages the Wish Book reached by 1968
1993
Year Sears announced the end of its general catalog
188
Pages in the revived full-line 2007 Wish Book
2017
Year Sears brought the Wish Book back for one last season

How the Size of the Sears Christmas Catalog Changed

1933 edition
87
1968 edition
605
1992 edition
832
2007 revival
188
2017 return
120
Source: Sears Archives and contemporary news reporting; the 1992 edition is reported at 832 pages in 2007 accounts and at 834 pages by AARP

A Timeline of the Sears Catalog and Wish Book

YearMilestone
1888First Sears catalog appears, selling only watches and jewelry
1900Catalog offers its first Christmas tree ornaments
1933First Sears Christmas Book is mailed, 87 pages, 25 of them toys
1968Catalog is officially named The Wish Book, reaching 605 pages
1993Sears announces the end of the Big Book on January 25; the Christmas Wish Book continues in smaller form
2007Full-line Wish Book revived at 188 pages; final regular edition in 2011; last return in 2017

If the memory tugs at you this week, it is easy to visit. An online archive of Sears history, kept at searsarchives.claeys.co, still lays out the dates and old catalog facts, and the Internet Archive has scanned some full editions you can page through on a screen.

Your local library or county historical society may hold bound catalogs too, so call ahead to ask what they have and how they let you handle it. Better still, start the ritual again at your own kitchen table.

Hand a grandchild any catalog or flyer that comes in the mail, give out a crayon, and let the circling begin. The toys have changed, but the act has not. Marking a page is still a free way of saying out loud what the heart hopes for.

Pass it along before another December slips by.

Sources

  • Sears Archives, When Did Sears Stop Distributing the Catalog? (archived at searsarchives.claeys.co)
  • The Washington Post, Goodbye, Book of Dreams (1993)
  • WRTV Indianapolis, 1993: Sears Closes the Book on Its Iconic Catalog
  • Sears Holdings, The Wish Book Catalog is Back! press release (2007)
  • CBS News, A Tattered Sears Revives Its Holiday Wish Book (2017)
  • CNN Money, Sears Revives Its Classic Wish Book (2017)